Sunday, March 28, 2010

Tim Wise responce.

Tim Wise made some very good points. I agree with his opinion that the election of Barack Obama is not the end all be all. I liked the point he made about the major events during the Civil Rights movement such as Brown v. The Board of Education, the Civil Right's Act of 1964, and such as all being steps...because that is what they were. I also liked his ideas of "racism 1.0" and "racism 2.0". I like this because one might imagine racism is dead because events where someone is lynched or the Ku Klux Klan is viewed as being a beneficial organization are exceedingly rare. More common is the racism depicted by Wise, such as saying that people embraced Obama because he was "more white". This draws some parallels with Delpit and the culture of power.

Here are a few points I tend to disagree with.

When Wise talks about people not being able to run for president because they wear their hair differently or dressing differently. Here is the thing...I don't think that is necessarily a racial thing but rather what the culture dictates is appropriate for a person to maintain a professional image. For example, say if a white person was running for president...but had shoulder length hair and a beard then I think there would definitely be problems during their campaigns. This is true even though vikings had long hair and beards and they were about as white as a person can be. Hell, they were even about as aryan as one could get too, so there is no way that someone is going to be discriminating over race. Going even further into this topic of what culture dictates is professional, we could look to the fact that no president since Taft has worn facial hair. That is not to say facial hair is bad, I sport it myself, but it just isn't what mass culture wants for their president or other politicians. Interestingly though, in academia facial hair is quite common and considered to be "professional".

The other thing was when he started talking about Will Smith. He was saying his comments as if Will Smith, because he is black should have an idea of the problems what all african-americans are feeling. It sounded as if Wise was suggesting that they have hive-minds and all face the same exact problems. It reminded me of what President Obama once said in regards to affirmative action and his daughters. He said something along the lines of how he does not think that his daughter's should be taken into account for affirmative action because they have far more opportunity then the vast majority of people in the country, whether they're white or a minority.

7 comments:

  1. i totally agree on you last point about will smith, i was kind of surprised that Wise brought it up, it was almost like he was shocked that he would say something like this

    ReplyDelete
  2. i agree with what you said at the beginning of your blog,,i think that electing Obama was a step in teh right direction, but there are many more strides that need to be overcome to end racism in the us

    ReplyDelete
  3. Jeff, I didn't think of the Will Smith comment like you did but know that you explain it I don't like how Wise put that. Thanks for making that point.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I agree with what you said about society dictating a certain standard that has more to professional image than race. I don't care if a person is black, white or purple, if they don't wear a suit and are unkempt they're more than likely not going to make it far in politics. However, I did think it was funny what he said about how the day black people can be as mediocre as whites and still be hired, is the day racism will be gone (in reference to Bush and other politicians). If Obama made constant mistakes in diction or demonstrated some personal failures in a public manner (a-la-Clinton), I think a lot of people would attribute it to his race.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Just like Beth said... There is a sort of double standard when it comes to race. Blacks seem to need to be great in the professional world while whites can be simply mediocre.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I totally agree with your comment about professional image. I admit that the suit and tie image is a part of western culture. But the simple fact is that western culture is dominating the world right now. African presidents in Africa wear the suit and tie too. Everyone in the world does, except some Middle Eastern Countries , but that is because they are simply anti-western and it has nothing to do with race. I hate how so many things get attributed to race when they really should not be. I think its annoying and its doing a disservice to the real issues blacks face.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I also agree with your comments about professional image and making it in politics. But if "Whites" believe they can get by being "simply mediocre" in the professional world like Kyle is saying in his blog especially in this economy then there will be pleantty of jobs for Aferican Americans soon!!!

    ReplyDelete